Top Cities for Long-Term Rentership
By and large, renters who remain in their homes longer signal more than just personal preference—they often indicate market stability, constrained supply, and a lower turnover rate. For real estate investors, that can translate into stronger cash flow, lower maintenance costs, and higher tenant reliability over time.
According to a recent Redfin report, a third (33.6%) of U.S. renters have lived in the same home for at least five years, up from 28.4% a decade ago. On a regional level, however, the popularity of long-term rentership varies—often shaped by local affordability, supply constraints, and demographic trends.
To better understand how renter stability is evolving, LendingOne analyzed Redfin’s historical tenure data to pinpoint the markets with both the largest current share of long-term renters and the most significant growth since 2013.
Topline findings
Inland California markets like Riverside, Stockton, and Bakersfield have seen long-term renter shares rise by over 15 percentage points since 2013.
Midwest metros like Dayton and Grand Rapids are also seeing a rise in long-term rentership, driven by aging populations, affordability pressures, and limited supply.
New York and Los Angeles have the highest share of renters staying 5+ years overall—driven by rent control, low turnover, and high ownership barriers that influence renters to stay put.
Where long-term rentership is climbing the most
In some markets, long-term renting has become the new normal. Specifically, California metros are seeing the biggest gains in long-term rentership due to a combination of housing shortages, rising home prices, and affordability pressures that make it harder for renters to move.
Limited new construction has further contributed to renters staying in place longer. In inland markets especially, these factors are locking tenants into longer stays—even as population and investor interest have grown.
Long-term rentership gains popularity in 48 of the largest 50 U.S. metros
Among the largest 100 U.S. metros, these are the 10 markets with the biggest percentage point jumps in long-term rentership from 2013 to 2023:
Riverside, CA: +18.0%
Stockton, CA: +16.7%
Bakersfield, CA: +16.2%
Sacramento, CA: +16.0%
Oxnard, CA: +15.1%
Fresno, CA: +14.9%
Dayton, OH: +14.5%
Las Vegas, NV: +13.5%
New Orleans, LA: +11.2%
Grand Rapids, MI: +11.1%
The markets where long-term rentership is already the norm
While some markets have seen the largest gains in long-term renters over the past decade, others already have a deeply rooted renter base. In these metros, renters staying five years or longer is the norm.
These markets tend to share certain traits: older housing stock, tighter rental supply, and higher barriers to homeownership, whether due to pricing or lending challenges.
For real estate investors, these markets may offer even more stability, with long-term tenants helping to ensure predictable income and lower turnover-related costs.
However, investors in these markets should proceed with caution. While high-tenure markets offer predictable income and lower turnover, they can also come with drawbacks. Strict rent controls and regulatory hurdles in these areas may limit rent increases, while older housing stock can mean higher maintenance costs.
Long-term rentership share in the largest 50 U.S. metros
Among the largest 100 U.S. metros, these are the 10 markets with the largest share of long-term renters in 2023:
New York, NY: 51.1%
Los Angeles, CA: 47.8%
Stockton, CA: 46.0%
Springfield, MA: 43.7%
Fresno, CA: 43.1%
Riverside, CA: 42.8%
New Haven, CT: 42.7%
Oxnard, CA: 42.0%
Allentown, PA: 40.8%
San Francisco, CA: 40.5%
Why national renter tenure is on the rise
A growing number of renters are staying in place longer—not necessarily because they want to, but because moving has become more difficult.
Affordability pressures are a significant driver. Home prices have surged since pre-pandemic, with the typical U.S. home price rising 49% from June 2019 to June 2025, according to LendingOne’s analysis of Zillow Home Value Index data. The result: many households are finding it harder to move, let alone transition into homeownership.
Year-over-year shift in home prices across the 50 largest metro area housing markets
In some regions, limited rental supply is also keeping turnover low, as tenants face fewer viable options when leases end. Additionally, an aging renter population and shifting lifestyle preferences are contributing to longer stays.
Big Picture
The rise in long-term rentership reflects a meaningful shift in the structure of the U.S. housing market. For many households, renting is no longer just a temporary phase—it’s a reality shaped by affordability constraints, demographic changes, and lifestyle preferences.
For investors, that shift presents both opportunities and risks. Markets with rising tenure may offer more predictable income, reduced turnover, and steadier occupancy. But they can also require longer-term strategies, especially in places with slower rent growth, tighter regulations, or an aging housing stock.